Name Game Revisited...

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.

For clarification, I can be considered a place although I am a thing.
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
 

Borsk

Administrator
Staff member
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace?

(NOTE: I'm assuming that you appear in the PT, since you do not appear in the OT and you do not "exclusively" appear in the EU. If this is correct, then answering this question should confirm that you appear in either TPM or AOTC.)
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace? Yes.

Borsk, the answer is yes, your assumption, however, is not logically sound. The Gundark appear in neither the OT nor the PT but could not be considered exclusively EU because there were references to Gundark in the OT (Han mentions pulling the ears off a Gundark) and the PT (Obi fell into a pit of Gundark). Thus while the Gundark have only appeared in the EU they are not exclusively EU. I am not, by any means, a Gundark, because I am not alive. I am not a earless dead Gundark because I am a place. So other than using them as an example to debunk your flawed logic you ought to completely ignore the Gundark unless you are in imminent danger of being eaten by one, in which case I propose you pull off its ears...
 

Borsk

Administrator
Staff member
Borsk, the answer is yes, your assumption, however, is not logically sound. The Gundark appear in neither the OT nor the PT but could not be considered exclusively EU because there were references to Gundark in the OT (Han mentions pulling the ears off a Gundark) and the PT (Obi fell into a pit of Gundark). Thus while the Gundark have only appeared in the EU they are not exclusively EU. I am not, by any means, a Gundark, because I am not alive. I am not a earless dead Gundark because I am a place. So other than using them as an example to debunk your flawed logic you ought to completely ignore the Gundark unless you are in imminent danger of being eaten by one, in which case I propose you pull off its ears...

By saying no to "are you in the OT", I take that to mean that the item did not appear in the OT. Looks like I need to differentiate between appearing in a movie or simply being referenced in a movie. For example, they talk about nerf herders in ANH, but I wouldn't say that nerf herders are in ANH. Further, they talk about Bothans in ROTJ, but there are no Bothans in ROTJ - they're just referenced. I'll be more specific with the question next time.
 

Borsk

Administrator
Staff member
Do you appear on Coruscant? (as in, you were seen on-screen on this planet) ;)
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace? Yes.
Do you appear on Coruscant?In a manner of speaking.
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace? Yes.
Do you appear on Coruscant?In a manner of speaking.
Is it likely that you will appear in all 3 prequels?It is more than likely, it has been confirmed.
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace? Yes.
Do you appear on Coruscant?In a manner of speaking.
Is it likely that you will appear in all 3 prequels?It is more than likely, it has been confirmed.
Are you the Imperial Palace?No.

Just a couple of notes. I am a place, but moreso a thing. Also while I must answer that I appear on Corruscant for fairness sake I could in good conscience say that I do not appear on Coruscant...
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace? Yes.
Do you appear on Coruscant?In a manner of speaking.
Is it likely that you will appear in all 3 prequels?It is more than likely, it has been confirmed.
Are you the Imperial Palace?No.
Are you the Jedi High Council? No.
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace? Yes.
Do you appear on Coruscant?In a manner of speaking.
Is it likely that you will appear in all 3 prequels?It is more than likely, it has been confirmed.
Are you the Imperial Palace?No.
Are you the Jedi High Council? No.
Are You a place on a ship? No.
 

Zepp

Interstellar Buccaneer
Are you in the OT? No.
Are you EU? Not exclusively.
Are you a character? No.
Are you a group? No.
Are you a race? No.
Are you on Naboo? No.
Are you a vehicle? No.
Are you a weapon? No. Not in the sense of a weapon that inflicts physical damage directly.
Are you a place? In the broad sense, yes.
Are you alive? No.
Are you a droid? No.
Are you mechanical? No.
Did you appear in The Phantom Menace? Yes.
Do you appear on Coruscant?In a manner of speaking.
Is it likely that you will appear in all 3 prequels?It is more than likely, it has been confirmed.
Are you the Imperial Palace?No.
Are you the Jedi High Council? No.
Are You a place on a ship? No.
Are you on the side of the trade federation? No.
 
Top